Reply: “Use of BIOME-BGC to simulate Mediterranean forest carbon stocks”
iForest - Biogeosciences and Forestry, Volume 4, Issue 5, Pages 249-249 (2011)
doi: https://doi.org/10.3832/ifor0594-004
Published: Nov 03, 2011 - Copyright © 2011 SISEF
Commentaries & Perspectives
Abstract
The current note responds to the critical contribution of Dr. Eastaugh on Chiesi et al. ([1]). That paper did not aim at applying BIOME-BGC to simulate stand growth, which requires a thorough modification of the model functions. In contrast, only a parameter setting was changed in order to adjust the predicted carbon storages during the simulation of quasi-equilibrium conditions. The adjustment was calibrated on volume statistics derived from the Tuscany forest inventory and is suitable for regional scale applications.
Keywords
Mediterranean forest, BIOME-BGC, Forest volume, Current annual increment
The critical contribution of Dr. Eastaugh is welcome and testifies to the widespread interest in this important research field ([3]). We have, however, the impression that he has not fully addressed the objectives of our study ([1]), as well as the assumptions used. Our investigation, in fact, was not aimed at modifying BIOME-BGC simulation of stand growth, as seemingly asserted by Dr. Eastaugh. As clearly highlighted in the paper introduction and conclusions, our objective was to adjust the carbon storages predicted by the model during its simulation of quasi-equilibrium (or steady state) conditions.
BIOME-BGC, at least in its original configuration, is not a growth model, since it does not simulate stand development and ageing, and trees are not individually represented ([2], S.W. Running - personal communication). The simulated ecosystems are composed of plants in various growing phases which mimic the age distribution of forests in natural conditions. More precisely, BIOME-BGC was developed to simulate the processes of natural biomes based on some key simplifying assumptions usable on regional levels ([8]).
This property is maintained in our approach. The BIOME-BGC versions used still simulate forests in steady state conditions. The modification proposed is only aimed at reducing long-term carbon accumulation in stems and coarse roots, which was found to be unreasonably high for some forest species (see also [5]). This modification was based on both volume values taken from local literature and volume measurements derived from the Tuscany regional forest inventory. In this latter case, no information was available about tree age distribution in the inventoried stands, which were likely uneven-aged. Thus, we simply used the statistical assumption that stands with maximum volumes approached quasi-equilibrium conditions, and these volumes were taken as corresponding to 90-95% of the potential ones.
Consequently, the new BIOME-BGC versions obtained are almost identical to the original ones, with the exception of the carbon accumulated in more stable tree compartments. These versions work with the same logic of the original model, and are therefore unsuited to simulate actively growing stands.
The strategy to account for departures from these potential conditions is based on a different rationale, which is fully exposed and discussed in Maselli et al. ([4]). That strategy still applies to forest ecosystems characterised by heterogeneous age distributions, and is not suited to simulate the growth and ageing of specific stands. To this aim, more complex modifications must be applied to the model functions, as is correctly done by other research groups (e.g., [9], [6], [7]).
References
CrossRef | Gscholar
Authors’ Info
Authors’ Affiliation
EcoGeoFor - Università del Molise, Contrada Fonte Lappone snc, I-86090 Pesche (IS - Italy)
Corresponding author
Paper Info
Citation
Chiesi M, Chirici G, Barbati A, Salvati R, Maselli F (2011). Reply: “Use of BIOME-BGC to simulate Mediterranean forest carbon stocks”. iForest 4: 249-249. - doi: 10.3832/ifor0594-004
Academic Editor
Marco Borghetti
Paper history
Received: Jul 27, 2011
Accepted: Aug 01, 2011
First online: Nov 03, 2011
Publication Date: Nov 03, 2011
Publication Time: 3.13 months
Copyright Information
© SISEF - The Italian Society of Silviculture and Forest Ecology 2011
Open Access
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-Non Commercial 4.0 International (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.
Web Metrics
Breakdown by View Type
Article Usage
Total Article Views: 50653
(from publication date up to now)
Breakdown by View Type
HTML Page Views: 44064
Abstract Page Views: 2316
PDF Downloads: 3150
Citation/Reference Downloads: 13
XML Downloads: 1110
Web Metrics
Days since publication: 4789
Overall contacts: 50653
Avg. contacts per week: 74.04
Article Citations
Article citations are based on data periodically collected from the Clarivate Web of Science web site
(last update: Feb 2023)
(No citations were found up to date. Please come back later)
Publication Metrics
by Dimensions ©
Articles citing this article
List of the papers citing this article based on CrossRef Cited-by.
Related Contents
iForest Similar Articles
Research Articles
Use of BIOME-BGG to simulate Mediterranean forest carbon stocks
vol. 4, pp. 121-127 (online: 01 June 2011)
Research Articles
Simplified methods to inventory the current annual increment of forest standing volume
vol. 5, pp. 276-282 (online: 17 December 2012)
Research Articles
Assessing most relevant factors to simulate current annual increments of beech forests in Italy
vol. 7, pp. 115-122 (online: 31 December 2013)
Research Articles
Modelling the carbon budget of intensive forest monitoring sites in Germany using the simulation model BIOME-BGC
vol. 2, pp. 7-10 (online: 21 January 2009)
Commentaries & Perspectives
Comment on Chiesi et al. (2011): “Use of BIOME-BGC to simulate Mediterranean forest carbon stocks”
vol. 4, pp. 248 (online: 03 November 2011)
Research Articles
Use of BIOME-BGC to simulate water and carbon fluxes within Mediterranean macchia
vol. 5, pp. 38-43 (online: 02 April 2012)
Research Articles
Incorporating management history into forest growth modelling
vol. 4, pp. 212-217 (online: 03 November 2011)
Research Articles
Scots pine’s capacity to adapt to climate change in hemi-boreal forests in relation to dominating tree increment and site condition
vol. 14, pp. 473-482 (online: 18 October 2021)
Research Articles
Local ecological niche modelling to provide suitability maps for 27 forest tree species in edge conditions
vol. 13, pp. 230-237 (online: 19 June 2020)
Research Articles
Modeling of early stage litter decomposition in Mediterranean mixed forests: functional aspects affected by local climate
vol. 8, pp. 517-525 (online: 18 November 2014)
iForest Database Search
Search By Author
Search By Keyword
Google Scholar Search
Citing Articles
Search By Author
Search By Keywords
PubMed Search
Search By Author
Search By Keyword